JournalismPakistan.com
July 03, 2024
JP Staff Reporter
ISLAMABAD—Daily Dawn on Wednesday criticized the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) for ordering telecom companies to implement a mass surveillance system, turning Pakistan into an Orwellian state.
In an editorial titled "Orwellian State," the paper stated, "PTA has forced telecom companies to implement a mass surveillance system through which up to 4 million citizens can be monitored at any given time with the click of a button."
The editorial commented on an order by Judge Babar Sattar of the Islamabad High Court, which revealed that telecom companies were mandated to "finance, import, and install" the Lawful Intercept Management System (LIMS) at a designated "surveillance centre" for use by designated agencies.
According to the order, "From the surveillance centre, a designated agency initiates a track and trace request through the click of a button, in relation to any SIM or IMEI number or MSISDN identity belonging to a consumer... the request goes through the LIMS in an automated manner, which is then connected with the network of telecom licensees."
The judge noted that citizens' data was being collected without human intervention or legal warrant, including "the entire content of communication between consumers undertaken through the network of the telecom licensee, including audio and video content and web page records," being shared with unnamed agencies, according to news reports.
The editorial highlighted the immense potential for abuse of such detailed information collected on citizens. "The fact that any citizen at any time can be made vulnerable by the state simply listening to and watching what they are doing and using that information to blackmail them would make anyone feel insecure."
The paper recalled the "leaked" phone calls involving prominent citizens that recently dominated news headlines and social media, prompting petitions from some affected individuals against intrusive state surveillance.
While acknowledging the justification for monitoring known criminals, terrorists, and foreign spies, the editorial argued that implementing a system to spy on ordinary citizens is a perverse abuse of power that must be stopped immediately. "The state must be required to secure legal warrants for initiating surveillance of any individual. Such immense power should not be accumulated by any institution as the potential for abuse and the consequences for personal freedoms can be disastrous."
July 06, 2024: Daily Dawn criticizes the Punjab government's request to shut down social media platforms during Muharram, highlighting concerns o...
July 05, 2024: Freedom Network responds to recent public controversy stemming from a Peshawar event. The statement addresses allegations of haras...
July 05, 2024: Javeria Siddique, wife of slain journalist Arshad Sharif, accuses the ruling elite of involvement in her husband's murder and dema...
July 03, 2024: Journalist Umar Cheema retracts his criticism of a Samaa TV talk show, alleging the episode where public speaker Sahil Adeem and p...
July 03, 2024: The teenage children of slain journalist Khalil Jibran fear for their lives after an arson attack on their snooker club. They have...
July 03, 2024: PTI accuses ARY News of broadcasting false news regarding a UN Working Group's report on Imran Khan's arrest. PTI asserts the repo...
June 30, 2024: Journalist Noor-ul-Arfeen Siddiqi was violently attacked by at least two dozen masked assailants at his home in Malir, leaving him...
June 30, 2024: Journalist Umar Cheema condemns public speaker Sahil Adeem and playwright Khalil ur Rehman Qamar for their disrespectful behavior ...
July 05, 2024 The Pulitzer Center is accepting applications for the 2024-2025 cohort of AI Accountability Fellows. These fellowships support journalists with funding, mentorship, and training to produce in-depth reporting on AI systems.
July 04, 2024 Journalist and government critic Aidos Sadykov succumbed to injuries on July 2 after a shooting in Kyiv. The IFJ, NUJU, and FEJK urge a thorough investigation by Kazakh and Ukrainian authorities.
July 04, 2024 Explore the progress and setbacks of press freedom in the Middle East. This article delves into the region's ongoing struggle for media independence, highlighting significant challenges and triumphs.
July 04, 2024 The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) urges Turkish authorities not to contest the appeals of eight journalists sentenced to over six years in prison on terrorism charges and calls for an end to the baseless prosecution of journalists. Learn more about the convictions and the appeals process.
July 03, 2024 The Committee to Protect Journalists welcomes the UN Working Group's declaration that the imprisonment of Guatemalan journalist Jose Ruben Zamora is arbitrary and calls for his immediate release. CPJ highlights the unjust prosecution faced by Zamora for his investigative reporting on government corruption.